During the past 50 years eleven pastors have served St. Joseph’s:
| Fr. Cranor Graves | March, 1968—December, 1970 |
| Fr. Kenneth Parker | January, 1970—October, 1971 |
| Msgr. Thomas Paul Hadden | October, 1971—February, 1973 |
| Fr. Francis R. Moeslein | February, 1973—September, 1976 |
| Msgr. James P. Keaney | September, 1976—July, 1980 |
| Msgr. Michael P. Shugrue | July, 1980—January, 1983 |
| Fr. James F. Keenan | January, 1983—July, 1986 |
| Fr. James M. Labosky | July, 1986—July, 1989 |
| Fr. JaVan J. Saxon | July, 1989—June, 1997 |
| Fr. Thanh Nguyen | July, 1997—December, 2002 |
| Msgr. John Williams | December, 2002— June, 2014 |
| Msgr. Jeffrey Ingham | June, 2014 - June, 2020 |
| Fr. Peter Devereux | July, 2020 - Present |